March 31, 2016 | By Ivo H. Daalder

This Week's Reads – Our Broken Borders


Stranded refugees and migrants try to bring down part of the border fence during a protest at the Greek-Macedonian border, near the Greek village of Idomeni, February 29, 2016. REUTERS/Alexandros Avramidis

When future historians try to understand today’s global era, they would be wise to study our borders. What they would find are telling symptoms of a world in retreat. Across Europe, an influx of migrants combined with a growing threat of terrorism may lead to a collapse of the border-free Schengen area—a potential Brexit would only make matters worse. Meanwhile, borders across the Middle East are in tatters. The Syrian civil war is ripping the region apart, and Russia’s recent maneuvering makes a political resolution seem distant. In the United States, we are seeing a growing movement to close off borders, for trade and security reasons. This would be a marked departure from over a half-century’s worth of US foreign policy. How did we get here? And what’s at stake? This week’s recommended reads help shed light on these questions and more.

EUROPE ON THE BRINK

A History of Errors Behind Europe’s Many Crises

Wolfgang Münchau/Financial Times

Münchau examines how a policy of minimal agreement has hamstrung the European Union’s capability to deal with security threats. Identifying four ways in which compromise has led to instability, he describes why distrust in the EU, and the possibility of disintegration, are rational reactions to current European crises.

It’s Time to Fix Europe – or Lose It

David Ignatius/The Washington Post

Ignatius lists five requirements that must be undertaken, from the grassroots to the international levels, to build a more secure Europe. Without significant changes, such as the assistance of immigrant communities to law enforcement agencies, intelligence sharing between European states, and better transatlantic partnerships, the future of Europe as we know it is in question.

A Quandary for Europe: Fighting a War on ISIS within Its Borders

Steven Erlanger/The New York Times

A dual response to the fight against ISIS is needed to avoid another Paris- or Brussels-style attack, according to Erlanger. Many of the perpetrators from both of these attacks were radicalized in poor and immigrant communities that feel alienated from the state, which fosters resentment. Easing the impoverished conditions of these self-isolated communities is vital to prevent a societal civil war.

Intelligence Agencies Fight to Unravel ISIS Networking in Europe

Sam Jones/Financial Times

European intelligence agencies underestimated the capabilities of domestic jihadist cells, which are now considered more of a threat to national security than the ability of ISIS to seize physical territory. The ISIS network is difficult to pinpoint due to independent operations and attack cells, each with its own mission and contacts. As ISIS loses territory in the Middle East, experienced fighters returning to Europe are likely to focus their attention on domestic campaigns.

Wake up – Britain is Heading for Brexit

Gideon Rachman/Financial Times

The strength behind Britain’s Vote Leave campaign has surprised London’s political establishment; unless pro-EU supporters speak up, a Brexit is likely. Escalating problems within the EU have provoked strong reactions from the British public, and those in the Vote Remain camp are less inclined to speak out than their counterparts. Rachman argues the pro-EU campaign will have to be bolstered by foreign leaders, including President Obama, if they want to avoid a Brexit.

TAKING STOCK IN SYRIA

The Scorpion’s Tale: Did Assad Take Putin for a Ride?

Anne Barnard/The New York Times

Russian’s military withdrawal from Syria coupled with Iran’s increasing support has made it nearly impossible to oust Assad. The Syrian president has proven his ability to play allies against each other and stall negotiations to his advantage, despite a protracted civil war and the West’s concerns with ISIS.

Learning from Vladimir

Bret Stephens/The Wall Street Journal

Stephens succinctly describes what the United States can learn from the Russian military intervention in Syria, concluding that the United States needs to rethink its strategies and goals if it wants to remain relevant in negotiations. While Putin’s methods have admittedly been reckless and violent, they have produced more concrete results and left Russia with more diplomatic influence in the region than the United States.

ON TERRORISM AND TRADE

Is America Next?

Daniel Benjamin/POLITICO

Benjamin, the former State Department coordinator for counterterrorism, says there’s a reason these terror attacks keep happening in Europe and not the United States. The differences between American and European Muslim populations, counterterrorism spending, and border security indicate a smaller chance of similar attacks on American soil. 

How Trade Made America Great

Frederick W. Smith/The Wall Street Journal

Smith gives a history of how trade has evolved and expanded since the Great Depression and how technological advances have contributed to the status and wealth of the United States. Open markets and a significant reduction in the cost of international travel have helped produce a multitrillion-dollar global trade market. The United States has benefited from past trade expansion and should continue to advocate for it.

NOTEWORTHY

Johan Cruyff, the Man Who Reinvented Football, Dies Aged 68

Simon Kuper/Financial Times

Dutch footballer Johan Cruyff was one of the true greats. He created what foreigners described as ‘Total Football,’ transforming AFC Ajax and the Dutch 1974 squad into a world-class teams. Also known for his argumentative style and tough demeanor, Cruyff’s legacy lives on in new generations of European football players.

About

The Chicago Council on Global Affairs is an independent, nonpartisan organization that provides insight – and influences the public discourse – on critical global issues. We convene leading global voices and conduct independent research to bring clarity and offer solutions to challenges and opportunities across the globe. The Council is committed to engaging the public and raising global awareness of issues that transcend borders and transform how people, business, and governments engage the world.

The Chicago Council on Global Affairs is an independent, nonpartisan organization. All statements of fact and expressions of opinion in blog posts are the sole responsibility of the individual author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Council.

Archive

| By Mira Rapp-Hooper, Brian Hanson

Deep Dish: Why Allies are Key for US Security Today

The Council on Foreign Relations’ Mira Rapp-Hooper joins Deep Dish to explain why the alliance system is still essential for America’s global leadership – but must be remade to meet the challenges of the 21st century. 




| By Adam Segal, Brian Hanson

Deep Dish: Who’s Winning the US-China Tech War?

The Council on Foreign Relations’ Adam Segal joins Deep Dish to explain the battles between China and the US over products like Huawei and TikTok, their role in US foreign policy, and why US allies are choosing sides. 


| By Judd Devermont, Neil Munshi, Brian Hanson

Deep Dish: Mali’s Instability Threatens the Sahel

This week on Deep Dish, the Center for Strategic and International Studies’ Judd Devermont and the Financial Times’ Neil Munshi explain why Mali’s instability is a threat to Africa’s Sahel region — soon to be the West’s largest conflict zone.






| By Catherine Belton, Brian Hanson

Deep Dish: How Putin Holds Power Over Russia

Investigative reporter Catherine Belton joins Deep Dish to examine the people that surround Russia’s enigmatic leader – and the financial ties to the West that makes the Kremlin’s dominance possible.