January 21, 2016 | By Ivo H. Daalder

This Week’s Reads

US President Barack Obama shakes hands with Saudi Arabia's King Salman after their meeting alongside the G20 summit at the Regnum Carya Resort in Antalya, Turkey, November 15, 2015. REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst

In a recent essay in The New York Times, former undersecretary of state Nicholas Burns writes about one of the central challenges of the Obama administration’s foreign policy: balancing diplomatic engagement with deterrence. His essay centers on Iran, but this challenge can be seen across many fronts. Take Syria, where former Obama advisor Dennis Ross says the United States hesitated to do more than offer pronouncements—creating a destabilizing power vacuum throughout the Middle East. Or look at China, which the Financial Times reports is ramping up activity in the contested waters of the South China Sea, despite US resistance.

By no means is this balancing act easy. Often, it takes strong and committed allies—which, for the United States, seem hard to come by these days. Old allies such as Saudi Arabia appear to be adding gasoline to a sectarian conflict that has engulfed the Middle East. Europe, meanwhile, is consumed with a migrant crisis, slow economic growth, and rising nationalism, all of which put a strain on transatlantic cooperation. Nevertheless, finding this balance between diplomacy and deterrence will be essential to grappling with America’s most difficult foreign policy challenges today and in the future.

With that, here are some of this week’s recommended reads:

Talk to Tehran, but Talk Tough

Nicholas Burns/The New York Times

Despite congressional criticism of rapprochement with Iran in the United States, Nicholas Burns argues there are clear benefits for American security. However, the road to a more normal relationship will be rocky, with one key challenge being its split government. Iran’s reformist president Hassan Rouhani is amenable to progress, but real power still rests with supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei—a recluse distrustful of the United States. In order to realize the long-term benefits of the nuclear deal with Iran, the United States must continue to balance engagement with deterrence.

How Obama Created a Mideast Vacuum

Dennis Ross/POLITICO

In nearly every meeting on Syria, President Obama reacted to possible ways to affect the Syrian civil war by asking “tell me where this ends.” He was right to ask this question, says his former senior Iran advisor Dennis Ross. But he should have also asked the corollary: What happens if we don’t act? Ross believes a vacuum was created by Obama’s hesitancy to act—an overcorrection from the Iraq war. That vacuum was filled by Iran, Hezbollah, and Iran’s other Shia militia proxies; Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and Qatar; Russia; and ISIL. Unless the United States does more now to fill this vacuum, Ross contends, the situation will spin further out of control.

Beijing Steps up Building in Disputed Waters despite US Resistance

Demetri Sevastopulo/Financial Times

China is forging ahead with a plan to build runways in the South China Sea in direct opposition to the wishes of the United States. Satellite images of Subi Reef and Mischief Reef reveal that the two reefs will be a part of the new landing strip on a third reef called Fiery Cross. Those opposed fear that China will militarize the islands and advance their claims over disputed territories and shipping lanes. However, President Xi Jinping says that the islands were made for civilian use. While many raise red flags about China’s activity in the area, there are some experts who believe that the fears are overblown.

Young Prince in a Hurry

The Economist

Muhammad bin Salman, the 30-year-old deputy crown prince who is the power behind the throne of his elderly father, King Salman, has a fast furious approach to wielding power. While his kingdom puts on airs of ostentatious luxury, he knows it faces serious trouble due to a failing economy and regional instability. He’s injecting new energy into government, taking gambles, and acting decisively. But critics note his transformation is indifferent to the democratic process and ignores demands for political liberalization and social justice reform.

The House of Saud's Sectarian Venom Spreads across Middle East

David Gardner/Financial Times

Saudi Arabia’s “execution spree” looks more defensive than powerful, says David Gardner in the Financial Times. In attempting to assert that the Arabian Peninsula is terra sancta for its brand of Sunni Islam, the kingdom opened a new front in the region with Iran-aligned Shias—one it will struggle to juggle with its pre-existing challenges of falling oil prices, an untried deputy crown prince, and dicey internal reforms.

Migrant Men and European Women

The Economist

The New Year’s Eve attack at a train station in Cologne, Germany, left more than 600 women robbed and sexually assaulted. Negative events such as this have raised questions from vocal critics as to whether or not European countries should be accepting asylum-seeking males. With the culture of migrants vastly different from that of Europeans, The Economist argues the responsibility now falls on Europe to educate refugees on European culture, while insisting migrants obey the law, to prevent acts of this nature from happening again.

Europe’s New Medieval Map

Robert Kaplan/The Wall Street Journal

What does turmoil look like on a map? According to Robert Kaplan it’s Europe during the middle ages, early modern era, or before the Industrial revolution. Europe, a continent with a tumultuous history has experienced a relatively peaceful couple of decades from 1950 to 2009. But since the start of the European Union’s debt crisis, it appears that things in Europe have reverted back to tumult. Europe is dealing with debt, an influx of migrants and refugees, and a more powerful Russia. With everything going on, the continent is once again splitting into two halves: Eastern Europe with the United States and Western Europe with Russia. Kaplan argues that “The continent’s map is becoming medieval again, if not yet in its boundaries then at least in its political attitudes and allegiances.”

Poland-EU: Stand-off in the East

Henry Foy and Duncan Robinson/Financial Times

The European Union is investigating Poland due to claims that recent laws passed by Poland’s Law and Justice Party violate democratic standards in the European Union. However, Beata Szydlo, the Prime Minister of Poland, is unconcerned. She says that Poland is sovereign, and therefore has the right to make sovereign decisions. Some argue the EU took formal action too quickly, arguing “now is not the moment for the EU to pick unnecessary fights.” Others believe Poland should fall in line: “They can shout at the beginning but they have to learn. They are part of the system.”

About

The Chicago Council on Global Affairs is an independent, nonpartisan organization that provides insight – and influences the public discourse – on critical global issues. We convene leading global voices and conduct independent research to bring clarity and offer solutions to challenges and opportunities across the globe. The Council is committed to engaging the public and raising global awareness of issues that transcend borders and transform how people, business, and governments engage the world.

The Chicago Council on Global Affairs is an independent, nonpartisan organization. All statements of fact and expressions of opinion in blog posts are the sole responsibility of the individual author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Council.

Archive

One More Question with Tyler Cowen

We asked Tyler Cowen, author of "The Complacent Class," how the American dream relates to America's foreign policy. See what he said.



| By Brian Hanson

Deep Dish: War and Peace in Asia

China’s military expansion in the South China Sea and rising economic influence command increasing attention, but North Korea, Japan, and other regional actors are shifting power beneath the surface. On the latest Deep Dish podcast, Asia experts Richard McGregor and Sheila Smith talk with host Brian Hanson about the intricate choices facing the Trump administration in Asia.



| By Ivo H. Daalder

This Week’s Reads – A Big Idea for Foreign Policy, Revisited

With the appeal of unconventional candidates and an onslaught of domestic and international crises, now may be as good a time as ever for new and daring policy ideas. What we need, writes Council President Ivo Daalder, is a robust debate about the importance of America's global leadership. This Week’s Reads examine some of the internal and external challenges to that American-led order, as well as some of the big ideas for reforming it. 



| By Ivo H. Daalder

Deep Dish: Trump's National Security Council

Will the appointment of H.R. McMaster as President Trump’s National Security Advisor calm the tumult over Michael Flynn’s resignation? On the latest Deep Dish episode, two former NSC members, Ivo Daalder and Kori Schake, illuminate the genuine challenges for McMaster and Trump’s national security machine from the inside out. 


| By Ivo H. Daalder

This Week's Reads – The Value of NATO

"The bottom line is that NATO today remains an essential tool in advancing both American and transatlantic interests” writes Council President Ivo Daalder. “The challenge moving forward is to ensure that the trust that underpins the alliance is not unraveled by mixed messages and uncertainty coming out of Washington." This Weeks’ Reads explores the current state of the transatlantic Alliance and some of the internal and external challenges it confronts. 


| By Brian Hanson, Salomón Chertorivski

City Diplomacy from Mexico City to Chicago

Mayors have to take care of their populations, and sometimes that means going to other countries. A delegation of Mexican mayors from Mexico City, Guadalajara, and Juarez came to Chicago to conduct city-to-city diplomacy during an "emergency time" in US-Mexico relations. Salomón Chertorivski, secretary of economic development of Mexico City, sat down with the Council's Brian Hanson to discuss what they hoped to achieve.



| By Brian Hanson, Cécile Shea

Deep Dish: US Intervention And Our Divided National Soul

Syria, Libya, and Iraq are the latest in a series of contentious US interventions. Forced to choose between leaving other countries alone or trying to run the world—Americans choose both, says author and journalist Stephen Kinzer. On this week's Deep Dish, Kinzer and career diplomat Cécile Shea discuss intervention done well, done poorly, and how the intervention debate has endured since the Spanish-American war. Subscribe now. 


| By Ivo H. Daalder

This Week’s Reads – Why Process Matters

The resignation of Michael Flynn as national security advisor "reveals an important truth, which all Presidents learn sooner or later, namely that when it comes to policy, process matters," says Council President Ivo Daalder. This Weeks Reads take a look at the major security issues facing the United States and provide some insights into the Trump administration’s approach to managing them.


| By Brian Hanson

Deep Dish: Don't Go to Russia on Your Knees

A flare-up of violence in eastern Ukraine following a call between presidents Putin and Trump has many wondering what’s next in the highly combustible situation. On this week's Deep Dish podcast, former US Ambassador to Ukraine John Herbst joins Russia expert Samuel Charap to analyze Putin’s goals and the likely outcome of a shift in Eurasian geopolitics.


| By Ivo H. Daalder

This Week's Reads – Culture and Conflict

In the early 1990's, famous political scientist Samuel Huntington posited a thesis that the major source of conflict in the post-Cold War world would not occur over ideological or economic fault lines, but cultural ones. Indeed, today we are beset with crises in the West and around the world—but to what degree is culture the cause? This Weeks Reads from Council President Ivo Daalder explores the ways in which culture is influencing our new era of global politics.


| By Kristin Ljungkvist

The Global City as Global Security Leader

The walled city once symbolized security. In these globalized times, leaders may build airports rather than walls, yet cities – not nations – once again increasingly stand on the front line of security.