June 23, 2016 | By Ivo H. Daalder

This Week’s Reads — Transatlantic Threats


NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg chairs a NATO defense ministers meeting at the Alliance headquarters in Brussels, Belgium, June 14, 2016. REUTERS/Francois Lenoir

What is the role of NATO in 2016 and beyond? This question will underpin much of next month’s NATO Summit in Warsaw, Poland, where leaders from across the Atlantic will gather to discuss new and emerging threats to the alliance. Given the diverse set of interests between the 28 member states, the answer is complicated.

There is no shortage of security crises affecting NATO allies. In the Middle East, there’s the urgent task of beating back ISIS and its affiliates. The Syrian Civil War, meanwhile, is hemorrhaging refugees into southern Europe and putting immense pressure on Turkey. Then there is the challenge of deterring Russia from further aggression in Ukraine and the Baltic states. 

These all pose significant challenges. And yet, the larger threat to the NATO alliance comes from within. On both sides of the Atlantic, nations are looking inward and turning toward nationalistic leaders who want to shirk global responsibilities. The most immediate example of this can be seen in this week’s British referendum to leave the European Union, or “Brexit.” But similar stories are cropping up elsewhere, in Hungary and, of course, in the United States.

NATO is still the world’s premier multinational political-military organization, but whether or not it remains so will ultimately depend on its members’ ability to fend off these corrosive, nationalistic forces within. This week’s reads looks at both the internal and external challenges confronting the NATO allies.

Unity of the West at Stake in Warsaw

Stefano Stefanini/European Leadership Network

The upcoming Warsaw Summit will test whether NATO is still relevant and capable of tackling the challenges of today, writes Stefano Stefanini. Europe faces increasingly complicated threats, and NATO must consider whether it is capable of preparing only for one kind of threat—a conventional, state-on-state conflict—or whether  threats extend beyond Russian aggression—especially as Russia and the NATO nations now share vulnerabilities from the Middle East and North Africa. Stefanini recommends that NATO address this by giving the MENA region appropriate attention, equipping itself against counterterrorism and working toward engaging more with Russia to increase transparency.

Shifting Attention to Mediterranean, NATO Fights Internal Dissent

Steven Erlanger/The New York Times

The secretary general of NATO, Jens Stoltenberg, has said that the alliance is discussing how to step up its presence in the Mediterranean in order to address the migrant crisis, even though not all NATO allies favor a move to scale up action. Turkey for one believes that the alliance’s limited resources should be focused on deterring Russia. Nevertheless, there is a general consensus that NATO members need to determine what its role will be in fighting terrorism and radical Islam, as well as addressing migration and unrest in the Middle East and North Africa.

Regardless of ‘Brexit’ Vote, Experts Say, European Union Must Rethink Status Quo

Jim Yardley/The New York Times

While the British desire to leave the European Union may be due to internal factors, experts say it is also largely due the European Union’s own failures. Dissatisfaction with the European Union has also caused xenophobic, reactionary parties and leaders to rise. Experts warn that if the European Union wants to stabilize, it must work to address a number of issues, including the structure of the euro zone, its Germany-centric policy focus, the refugee crisis, the rise of xenophobia, and disparities across its countries. These reforms will be necessary regardless of whether Britain stays or goes.

From Great Britain to Little England

Neal Ascherson/The New York Times

Rising xenophobia and resentment toward the European Union have been behind the Leave campaign in Europe, argues Neal Ascherson. But a deeper British, particularly English, sentiment of being separate from Europe has also been an important driver; English discontent and a feeling of underrepresentation is a large motivator. Ascherson argues, however, that citizens should have looked to London’s politics rather than politics in Brussels to remedy this issue. Leaving Europe will not grant English citizens more control but rather leave their country less regulated, more unequal, and without access to the single EU market.

What Obama Actually Thinks About Radical Islam

Jeffrey Goldberg/The Atlantic

Despite criticism from Trump and others, Jeffrey Goldberg says President Obama’s commitment to fighting radical Islam is unquestionable. The criticism stems from Obama’s desire to avoid alienating Muslims around the world by using the term “radical Islam” and painting them with a broad brush. But according to Goldberg, this resistance to the phrase this does not mean Obama is indifferent about fighting the threat.

American Attitudes on Refugees from the Middle East

​Shibley Telhami/Brookings Institution

As the global refugee crisis escalates, American willingness to accept refugees from the Middle East has become a prominent issue in the presidential race. Shibley Telhami surveyed the American public and found that 59 percent of respondents supported the United States taking in more refugees from the Middle East and Syria (assuming they have been through security checks). Democrats and millennials were on average more likely to be supportive of accepting refugees, and Trump supporters were more opposed to taking in refugees than Republicans on average.

Before Obama Leaves Offices, Here’s What He Should Do about Iran

​Zalmay Khalilzad and James Dobbins/The Washington Post

As President Obama’s term comes to a close, Zalmay Khalilzad and James Dobbins recommend he work to establish a favorable balance of power with Iran—working with partners to limit threats from the regime but also engaging Iran to settle regional conflicts and defeat ISIS. The authors also contend that Obama should enhance communication between the two countries so that contact is maintained beyond small inner circles. Whether it’s through a full resumption of diplomatic relations or something more incremental, Khalilzad and Dobbins believe the Middle East can only be stabilized when the United States engages directly with Iran.​

Obama’s Drone Revamp Gives Military Bigger Responsibility, Keeps CIA Role

Adam Entous and Gordon Lubold/The Wall Street Journal

A long-promised plan by President Obama allows for increased transparency around drone strikes and helps settle a debate regarding the CIA’s quasi-military role. The plan involves last-minute military takeovers of drones on CIA missions. If the military takes control right before missiles are launched, then the US military will technically be responsible for the strikes—even when the CIA’s drones and intelligence are used. That would allow the operations to be disclosed after the fact, adding transparency to help counter the narrative that US drone strike use is heavy-handed. 

About

The Chicago Council on Global Affairs is an independent, nonpartisan organization that provides insight – and influences the public discourse – on critical global issues. We convene leading global voices and conduct independent research to bring clarity and offer solutions to challenges and opportunities across the globe. The Council is committed to engaging the public and raising global awareness of issues that transcend borders and transform how people, business, and governments engage the world.

The Chicago Council on Global Affairs is an independent, nonpartisan organization. All statements of fact and expressions of opinion in blog posts are the sole responsibility of the individual author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Council.

Archive

| By Brian Hanson, Kori Schake, James Lindsay

Deep Dish: End of the Line with North Korea?

With news that North Korea may have the capability to launch a miniaturized nuclear weapon on an intercontinental ballistic missile, can the North Korea can be kicked any further down the road? In this summer bonus episode, Brian Hanson discusses with Kori Schake and Jim Lindsay, alums of the national security council and leading voices in foreign policy and national security.





Top 5 Deep Dish Podcasts of 2016-17

As part of the Council’s mission to provide insight and influence the public discourse, we created Deep Dish on Global Affairs, a podcast that goes beyond the headlines on critical global issues. With foreign policy and international relations in constant flux, Deep Dish brings together experts in politics, government, defense, finance, and wherever the news is happening to dig deep into current affairs.



| By Demetrius Amparan

If I Were Mayor

In a flash talk delivered at the 2017 Chicago Forum on Global Cities, poet Demetrius Amparan spoke about what he would do if he were mayor.


One More Question with Gideon Rachman

We asked Gideon Rachman, chief foreign affairs columnist at the Financial Times, for his thoughts about the shifting balance of global economic power between the East and the West. See what he said.


7 Summer Reads from the Council's Stage

Summer reading lists are about as ubiquitous this time of year as sunburns and cookouts, but not all of them exhibit a global affairs oeuvre. Here are seven great works featured in the 2016-17 Council program season that you can learn from, as well as videos of the authors speaking on the Council stage. 



One More Question with Ruchir Sharma

We asked Ruchir Sharma, Morgan Stanley's Chief Global Strategist, which country was best poised for economic growth and which country presented the greatest risk to the global economy. See what he said.





Top 5 "One More Question" Videos

The Council works hard to bring the brightest minds to Chicago to share their ideas on important global issues. With so much to discuss, it is sometimes difficult to fit all that there is to say on a subject into a single event. That's why we invited several of our guests to answer questions that may have gone unanswered. We’ve been releasing these brief interviews as part of our One More Question series. Discover our top five most popular episodes to date.