Guest Commentary – How Access to Long-Established Technology Can Help Feed Growing Cities
The first gasoline-powered tractor rolled down a Midwestern wheat field in 1892. Since then, this technology has evolved and spread around the world—but it has spread unevenly. While globally there are 196 tractors for every 100 square kilometers of arable land, that number is just 6.6 in Nigeria.
The rising cost of agricultural labor, driven in part by rural-to-urban migration, has represented a significant expense for smallholder farmers who must hire day laborers to manually prepare their fields. If farmers hired a tractor to do that work instead, they could use the money they save to invest in their farms and improve their yields; but with few providers offering tractor services in the country, most Nigerian smallholders do not have that option.
An Obstacle to Growth
These kinds of problems are common for farmers in developing countries. Farmers in high-income countries, for example, use nearly ten times more fertilizer per acre as those in low-income countries do. That is part of the reason why there is a wide gap in farm productivity between low-income and high-income countries: farmers in the 54 Low-Income, Food-Deficit Countries (LIFDCs), for example, harvest cereal yields just one-third the size of those of their counterparts in the United States.
With better access to well-established technologies, farmers in developing countries could boost their yields, earn higher incomes, and increase the supply of food available to the world’s growing cities. How can that access be improved?
As shown in Nigeria by the Propcom Mai-Karfi program, an initiative funded by the United Kingdom’s Department for International Development and implemented by a consortium of organizations led by Palladium and including TechnoServe, the answer can often lie in supporting private sector investment and commercial relationships that get technology onto smallholders’ farms.
Getting More Tractors Where They’re Needed
In Nigeria, the public sector had subsidized a limited number of private tractor purchases and owned a small number of tractors for use on farmers’ fields. But supply fell far short of demand: there were just 20,000 tractors in a country that needed at least 70,000 (and potentially as many as 300,000) tractors. Because spare parts and maintenance were not properly budgeted for, only about half of the machines were working. Under this model, private tractor owners could not get the equipment they needed to expand their fleets, and smallholder farmers could not receive the ploughing services that they needed to run their farms more efficiently.
The Propcom Mai-Karfi program staff works with tractor distributors, lenders, and various national tractor owner associations to forge new linkages and support a sustainable commercial model in which tractor owners provide farmers with ploughing services for a small fee. The project helps the tractor distributors to improve their sales and marketing channels to reach private-sector buyers, and the distributors have decentralized their operations in order to better serve their customers. The project also works with banks to create credit products that would enable the purchase of tractors; in order to reduce the risk to banks and stimulate private sector financing, the program has provided various types of financing guarantees. To improve the quality of services provided to smallholders and ensure that the provision of those services would be profitable for the tractor operators, the project has helped the tractor operators’ association to develop specialized training on mechanized agriculture.
The project is still on-going, with aims to scale. But in 2014 and 2015, it led to the distribution of approximately 94 tractors. Since a tractor can reach approximately 300 smallholder farmers each year, with an estimated annual cost saving of $50 in land preparation cost, each tractor is generating $15,000 of annual incremental income for farmers in the community. Because the model is built on profitable commercial relationships between farmers, tractor operators, distributors and lenders, the progress observed so far should be sustained and even grow.
Approaches like this, which harness private investment in the agricultural sector, are crucial for getting new and long-established technology into the hands of those who have been left behind. Ultimately, this will be vital for feeding the world’s growing population.
About
The Global Food and Agriculture Program aims to inform the development of US policy on global agricultural development and food security by raising awareness and providing resources, information, and policy analysis to the US Administration, Congress, and interested experts and organizations.
The Global Food and Agriculture Program is housed within the Chicago Council on Global Affairs, an independent, nonpartisan organization that provides insight – and influences the public discourse – on critical global issues. The Council on Global Affairs convenes leading global voices and conducts independent research to bring clarity and offer solutions to challenges and opportunities across the globe. The Council is committed to engaging the public and raising global awareness of issues that transcend borders and transform how people, business, and governments engage the world.
Support for the Global Food and Agriculture Program is generously provided by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
Blogroll
1,000 Days Blog, 1,000 Days
Africa Can End Poverty, World Bank
Agrilinks Blog
Bread Blog, Bread for the World
Can We Feed the World Blog, Agriculture for Impact
Concern Blogs, Concern Worldwide
Institute Insights, Bread for the World Institute
End Poverty in South Asia, World Bank
Global Development Blog, Center for Global Development
The Global Food Banking Network
Harvest 2050, Global Harvest Initiative
The Hunger and Undernutrition Blog, Humanitas Global Development
International Food Policy Research Institute News, IFPRI
International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center Blog, CIMMYT
ONE Blog, ONE Campaign
One Acre Fund Blog, One Acre Fund
Overseas Development Institute Blog, Overseas Development Institute
Oxfam America Blog, Oxfam America
Preventing Postharvest Loss, ADM Institute
Sense & Sustainability Blog, Sense & Sustainability
WFP USA Blog, World Food Program USA
Archive
Guest Commentary – Food Security Is Essential to Our National Security
The latest post in the Agri-Pulse and Council column series features Lieutenant General John Castellaw, on the linkage between food security and national security.
Guest Commentary – Lessons from Dr. Borlaug: Overcoming the Divisions of Today for a Food-Secure 2050
Tara Mittelberg of Northwestern University reflects on how the legacy of Norman Borlaug can be applied to today's global food security challenges.
Stability in the 21st Century: Maximizing Private Sector Engagement
The third recommendation from our recent report, Stability in the 21st Century, offers actions that the US government can take to leverage the power of the private sector in promoting global agricultural development.
Big Ideas and Emerging Innovations
Highlighting approaches, technologies, and ideas that have the potential to radically advance global food security.
Seizing the Opportunity: Ag Trade in the Era of Trump
Grace Burton discusses the opportunity presented to US agriculture by the Trade Facilitation Agreement, as highlighted in a recent Council report.
Stability in the 21st Century: Expanding Research Capacity for Innovation in Agriculture
Check out the second post in our series highlighting recommendations from the new report, Stability in the 21st Century: Global Food Security for Peace and Prosperity.
Big Ideas and Emerging Innovations
Highlighting approaches, technologies, and ideas that have the potential to radically advance global food security.
Guest Commentary – UC Berkeley Supply Chain Conference Promises Diverse Perspectives on Innovation
As UC Berkeley’s College of Natural Resources gears up for its upcoming conference, “Strategic Perspectives on Innovation in Agrifood Supply Chains”, check out a preview of the topics and speakers who will be presenting at the event.
Stability in the 21st Century: Integrating Engagement on Food Security and National Security
Beginning this week, the Council will highlight recommendations from the new report, Stability in the 21st Century: Global Food Security for Peace and Prosperity, in a weekly blog series.
Feeding 2050: Blockchain – A Levelled Global Playing Field
As part of our Science, Food, and Equity series, Marcus Glassman discusses how blockchain can promote agricultural development in emerging markets.
Big Ideas and Emerging Innovations
Highlighting approaches, technologies, and ideas that have the potential to radically advance global food security.
Guest Commentary – Not Your Grandma’s FBO: Today’s Faith-Based Organizations Play a Key Role in Global Food Security
Daniel Speckhard of Lutheran World Relief on the important role that faith-based organizations play in promoting global food security.
Guest Commentary – Trade and Development, a Winning Combination for the World
Jim Hershey of WISHH on the role that soy plays in food security and agricultural development.
Guest Commentary – On the Precipice of an Agricultural Triumph or Hardship: Tackling Food Insecurity by 2050
Daniel O’Neill Vogwill, high schooler at the Chicago High School for Agricultural Sciences, discusses his perspective on global food security as an urban student in a rural industry.
Guest Commentary – Bees Are Better than Barriers
Dr. Oscar Castañeda of Heifer International on how agricultural development can help people facing migration decisions stay at home more feasibly.
